Archive

I’m Feeling Lucky: The Confessions of Google Employee Number 59

Im Feeling Lucky

After listening to few audiobooks with the last being “The Steve Jobs Way: iLeadership for a New Generation” I bought this book from my Audible monthly Gold subscription about 2 months back. The audio version is in two parts (8 hours each) and the best part it was read by the author “Douglas Edwards” himself.

Douglas Edwards joined Google as its 50 something employee on November 29, 1999 just about a year after founding and full 5 years till March 4, 2005 before its stunning IPO in 2004. Before Google he was working for San Jose Mercury News, a 150 year old newspaper managing their online product “Merc” (The Newspaper of Silicon Valley). Douglas was the first director of Google managing its early days marketing and brand management, much of what we saw of initial days Google marketing was written by him. He has penned the text and documentation of many of the early products the mountain view firm. One of the first products for which he wrote the welcome text was for Google Toolbar for which he wrote the below “…NOT THE USUAL YADA YADA” text, he seems to be so thrilled by this line that he repeats it often in the book.

image

Douglas recalls about the early crazy days of working in Google, late nights, mid night emails to getting to office next day early morning. His encounters with the Chef Charlie, interactions with Larry & Sergey, Product managers like

He recalls tales of how everyone in Google helped to add server capacity in their data center just before big customers like Yahoo! or AOL signed up. How Will Whitted, Hardware Engineer of Google designed Machines so cheap that they don’t need to care if they fail – this is something that all new age computing firms including FaceBook, Amazon seems to take advantage of today.The author goes into explaining what he saw happening on how Google won many of its early deals with Yahoo!, later with ISP as first customer for Adwords & then the biggest of all AOL

In the later chapters as Google evolves & grows big, teams were formally divided Douglas recalls many occasions where he was constantly in struggle with Marissa Mayer who was managing Product Development and Douglas was managing Branding & Marketing. What Douglas leaves out, probably we readers can guess the reason for Larry to be siding with Marissa was because he was dating her then. Douglas seems to have had a better relationship with other early product managers including Salar Kamangar (9th employee and presently CEO of YouTube).

Douglas talks of many Holiday parties at Google, how extravagant they were and the facilities in Googleplex. He talks of the founders obsession with trying to solve everything with Engineering & Algorithms, not having empathy or respect for conventional way of working with people & companies, sometimes this bordering on arrogance. He recalls how the founders disliked to spend money for vendors, they wanting a vendor of a CRM system they wanted to buy to give it free for the privilege of having Google as their customer. In the end how they went with a not so popular CRM solution to manage the thousand of email pouring in to Google from users and all the problems they had till finally writing an email & CRM system on their own. He recalls of what they did immediately after 9/11, pouring into Web logs trying to dig any clue that may be useful for security agencies.

Douglas talks on how Google went searching the next billion dollar idea after search’s success – how it accidentally got GMail! and Google News. He talked on how he got into preparing company’s IPO documentation, how he parked his car miles away from the Investment banking firm handling the deal.

An interesting book to read if you are interested to know the true Google story.

Google translate supports Tamil

Having not seen any new successful product announcements from Google for last year or so I was feeling Google is losing its magic touch, it is getting bogged down by its own size and return of Larry Page is going to do little to change course. When I make the previous comment, I am not counting Android or Google Chrome announcements made me in recent Google I/O – those are enhancements, what I am talking is fundamental innovation.  But today something happened that made pause this thought for a while and give credit to Google for its basic computer science research and its leadership position.  It is the release of support in Google Translate for 5 Indic Languages including my mother tongue “Tamil”.

Though many research labs with their computer scientists & linguists both in India & outside are working on this for more than last 3 decades, having a publicly accessible Tamil translator has always remained a dream. I have personally met many of these great minds during the INFITT Tamil Internet conferences, but unfortunately they were all few critical steps away from completing their great work due to resource constraints. Many of these projects were also happening in silos – Private firms research arms, Government funded academic labs, Universities Linguistic departments and so on.

Though it is in Alpha stage and is far from perfect, it is a big day for all Tamilians. What Google has released today at Translate.Google.com is two-way translation (To Tamil & From Tamil) :

1. English (and other languages) to Tamil: The “Tamil” only speakers of Tamil Nadu & around the world can now access and enjoy the vast majority of World Wide Web without being hampered by not having English proficiency.

MaalaiMalar-Translated-To-English

2. Tamil to English (and other languages): The entire world can now enjoy the timeless treasures in Tamil literature and written by Tamil poets.

wsj-translated-to-tamil

Is Google losing the shine?

Google-Search

I am half-way through reading the book Googled when it struck me the thought that has become this post. Reading the book you are awe-stuck on Google’s initial years, the story of how the founders acted, their extraordinary vision & brilliance, their boldness touching arrogance are all unbelievable. Though many of us who were over 20s when Google was founded has lived through their growth, still when you read it chronicled we realize that this is a company that was so disruptive, so unconventional, so transformational in the first years of its life itself. Then suddenly when I started thinking about Google in the present term (2011), I felt not so cool or exciting about them.

The thoughts that go through my mind as I now think of Google are:

FaceBook is the new darling of the Silicon Valley. You have read stories about the Google struggling to retain their brightest people and fresh A-Grade talent are choosing FaceBook over Google.

Google’s strength always has been the amount of information it has – about People their interest, what they search, when they search, what advertisements works and so on. Now FaceBook seems to be doing one-up in this, FB knows more about individuals – they know who my friends are, what they like and they know that in real-time from my updates. And people spend good part of their day in FaceBook, where as in Google they visit & immediately leave Google.

After their initial wave of product releases (or acquisitions) including Adwords, AdSense, GMail, Google News, YouTube, Blogger, Picasa, Google Books, Google Maps, Google Chrome which were innovative & in rapid succession, you are finding things have become slow. (Let us look into new innovations in later points). The last major release I remember of Picasa, YouTube, Google News or GMail were years ago. Blogger is certainly aging and crying for an update whereas WordPress is shining with new features all the time. Google Docs is evolving ever more slower. There has been incremental updates like Microsoft has been doing for last 2 decades with Windows & MS Office, but nothing that’s disruptive like Apple is able to come out with each release.

After the initial lead I am not finding Google Apps to be offering any compelling value over competition. Microsoft has been successful in stemming migration to Google Docs, infact Microsoft has grown its revenues from MS Office pretty well over the last few years much more than expected. When it comes to cloud you hear Amazon AWS, Windows Azure & SalesForce more often than Google App Engine.

Apple which was basically a Hardware/OS firm is now the biggest media retailer (Music, Movies) and is one of the the biggest Online Services firm from new markets that it created from nowhere (Books, Apps) – where as Google is nowhere in any of these. I have used Android Marketplace and it pales in comparison even to Microsoft Zune/Windows Phone Marketplace and certainly not in the same league as Apple App Store in terms of technology, user experience & developer experience. Android is also plagued with the problem of heavy fragmentation and so far no plans from Google to address it for benefit of developers & users.

When a company like Google which has grown exponentially every year for last ten years in terms of revenues and resources (people & infrastructure) it is natural to be having big expectations and innovations coming out every year. In recent years, Google has come up only with Android which has become a hit. Google Wave was a disaster, Chrome OS is having release delays & predictions from IT pundits of being born dead, Orkut is an also run, Open Social a failed show of strength and PayPal clone Google Checkout has had few takers. Many of the recent announcements from Google have not got the same WorldWide PR attention like in the earlier days. The next wave of growth in Tech World is undoubtedly the Social & Cloud – Google is not the leader in any of this.

It is not surprising to hear bad things about Google especially from Steve Ballmer and then from Carol Bartz – who both have called Google a “One Trick Pony” at various times, but I find it to be more true than ever. Google has been very successful in defending its turf on Search for almost 10 years now, it has been constantly improving it, it has got releases in quick successions and almost always the product turned out to be superior in technology than the competition. Bing! is catching up (due to Yahoo! acquisition & fairly good product) but still Google is able to maintain its lead comfortably. The entry barrier in this field is phenomenal for any entrant here.

So what will the next ten years of Google will be – that’s the billion(s) dollar question. One thing we can be certain is that the road ahead for the incoming CEO Larry Page from April 1st is not going to be smooth. All the best for Mr.Page

Search Engines becoming smarter

I searched for articles on India’s performance in Beijing Olympics so far and so I typed in Google “India Olympics”. I was surprised to the see the first result as the medal count tally (see screen shot below). Checked it in Live Search as well on how smart it was behaving. It too gave similar results and added more details than Google. If Search Engines improve at this same rate, I guess we will one day have them answer any question we throw at them (Do you think this will happen or it is only a science fiction, please post it in the comments)

Google output for India Olympics, showing Medal TallyLive Search output for India Olympics, showing Medal Tally

Google Image Search







Today out of curiousity I did a search of my name in Google Image Search. To my surprise I came across the page of Tamil Internet 2001 Conference held in Malaysia. There I found this photo of Prof.M.Anandhakrishnan, Mr.Muthu Nedumaran, Dr.N.Kannan & me in a plenary session. 


Interesting isn’t it? :-)